Skip to content
Criminal Justice New York State Budget

Hochul Wants to Revisit Another Criminal Justice Reform: State of the State 2025

After years of targeting bail, the governor is proposing changes to New York’s 2019 discovery reform law.

Chris Gelardi   ·   January 15, 2025
| Photos: Governor Kathy Hochul; Beyond My Ken / Wikimedia Commons; Elia Clerici / Pexels | Illustration: Leor Stylar
Read all our coverage of the governor's 2025 agenda:
Staying Focused
Sign up for our free newsletter, and we'll make sure you never miss a beat.
BlueSky Tweet Share Email Link Republish

In her annual State of the State address Tuesday, Governor Kathy Hochul proposed for the third time altering New York’s 2019 criminal justice reforms.

This year, the changes revolve around discovery, a process in criminal trials that requires prosecutors to share evidence with the defense. Her proposals so far are vague, and the legal mechanics at play are complex.

Before the 2019 reforms, under a statute pejoratively known as the “blindfold law,” prosecutors could leave defendants in the dark by waiting until right before trial to hand over evidence. Now, they must do so on a deadline, giving the defense an opportunity to use the materials to build their case; if they don’t, judges can dismiss the charges.

Among other provisions, Hochul wants to make it harder for judges to dismiss cases when prosecutors fail to share materials. Her State of the State policy book released Tuesday describes the proposal as a minor change that would close a “loophole” that prompts judges to dismiss otherwise strong cases.

“We do not want to change the original spirit of the law,” Marcos Gonzalez Soler, Hochul’s deputy secretary for public safety, told New York Focus.

But public defenders worry that Hochul’s changes would gut the heart of discovery reform.

“The governor’s proposal would allow prosecutors to disregard these timeframes in every single case, move forward without providing all of the evidence, and shift the burden to the defense to request evidence in order to obtain it,” said Eli Northrup, criminal defense policy director for The Bronx Defenders.

District attorneys complain that judges are dismissing cases after prosecutors have, through no fault of their own, come across new materials after the discovery deadline. And they blame defense attorneys for playing into that dynamic.

“The statute in its current form lends itself to combative gamesmanship from defense counsel and the wholesale dismissal of cases across the state on technicalities,” said Richmond County District Attorney Michael McMahon, president of the District Attorney Association of the State of New York.

The reform law dictates that judges should only dismiss cases for discovery reasons if a prosecutor fails to exercise “due diligence” in turning over the required material. New York’s highest court affirmed that standard in December 2023, listing six criteria for judges to consider when determining whether a prosecutor exercised due diligence.

“The statute does not require or anticipate a ‘perfect prosecutor,’” Judge Caitlin Halligan wrote for the court.

“Diligent prosecutors are not penalized for inadvertent mistakes,” the Legal Aid Society said in a statement.

Asked whether the court case makes Hochul’s discovery adjustments moot, Gonzalez Soler said that his office ran them by the Office of Court Administration. They responded positively — suggesting, he argued, that Hochul’s proposal is still needed.

“Otherwise, they would have said, ‘Why do you need that?’” he said.

Hochul’s policy book outlines other changes to the discovery law: “clarifying” exactly what types of evidence prosecutors have to produce; automatically redacting personal information unrelated to a case; and reducing the amount of notice required before a defendant’s statements can be presented to a grand jury.

The full scope of those proposals, too, won’t be fully known until the governor’s office releases more details.

BEFORE YOU GO, consider: If not for the article you just read, would the information in it be public?

Or would it remain hidden — buried within the confines of New York’s sprawling criminal-legal apparatus?

I started working at New York Focus in 2022, not long after the outlet launched. Since that time, our reporters and editors have been vigorously scrutinizing every facet of the Empire State’s criminal justice institutions, investigating power players and the impact of policy on state prisons, county jails, and local police and courts — always with an eye toward what it means for people involved in the system.

That system works hard to make those people invisible, and it shields those at the top from scrutiny. And without rigorous, resource-intensive journalism, it would all operate with significantly more impunity.

Only a handful of journalists do this type of work in New York. In the last decades, the number of local news outlets in the state has nearly halved, making our coverage all the more critical. Our criminal justice reporting has been cited in lawsuits, spurred legislation, and led to the rescission of statewide policies. With your help, we can continue to do this work, and go even deeper: We have endless ideas for more ambitious projects and harder hitting investigations. But we need your help.

As a small, nonprofit outlet, we rely on our readers to support our journalism. If you’re able, please consider supporting us with a one-time or monthly gift. We so appreciate your help.

Here’s to a more just, more transparent New York.

Chris Gelardi
Criminal Justice Investigative Reporter
Chris Gelardi is a reporter for New York Focus investigating the state’s criminal-legal system. His work has appeared in more than a dozen other outlets, most frequently The Nation, The Intercept, and The Appeal. He is a past recipient of awards from Columbia… more
More by Chris Gelardi Bluesky Signal Twitter Email
Also filed in Criminal Justice
Hochul and Legislators, Urging Action on Prisons, Are Poised for a Fight on Other Public Safety Policies

The legislature rejected Hochul’s central public safety policy priorities while embracing proposals to increase prison oversight.

Chris Gelardi
When Conviction Integrity Units Exonerate the Innocent, Prosecutors Escape Blame

In New York, half of CIU exonerations involve prosecutorial misconduct, but DAs rarely acknowledge who got it wrong.

Ryan Kost and Oishika Neogi
Four Takeaways From Our Investigation Into New York’s Judicial Patronage Problem

No time to read our big investigation? Here’s a quick summary of everything you need to know.

Chris Bragg
Also filed in New York State
The Upper Class Will Save the Most From Hochul’s ‘Middle-Class’ Tax Cut

The biggest winners from the proposed break make well above New York’s median income.

Sam Mellins
Lawmakers Push for Fairer School Funding, Higher Aid

The governor’s proposal could leave 24 districts with less Foundation Aid than expected. The one-house budgets aim to fix that.

Bianca Fortis
Legislature Proposes Boost to Nonprofits and Safety Net Programs Serving New York’s Neediest

Nonprofits form the backbone of the state’s social service sector, and they may be getting some overdue relief in this year’s budget.

Jie Jenny Zou
Also filed in Budget
How New York Focus Tackled the 2025 State Budgets

A peek behind the curtain of how our reporters were able to analyze hundreds of pages of complicated budget documents (without losing their minds).

Alex Arriaga
Legislature Proposes More Money for Child Care, But Not Enough to Avert Funding Cliff

The budget plans set up a fight with Governor Kathy Hochul, who did not propose substantial new investments at all.

Julia Rock
Millionaire Tax Hikes? Inflation Rebate Checks? New York’s 2025 Budget Showdown

Here’s what the key players in the state budget process are proposing on spending and taxes.

Sam Mellins
Complete your gift to make an impact